The bridges of Antique and climate change

Photo by Bombo Radyo

While browsing Facebook on Monday, I saw the Paliwan Bridge in Bugasong, Antique had collapsed. Its approaches were washed away so the bridge is now in the middle of a river- a scene that brings back childhood memories of my dangerous and arduous journey through raging rivers during the rainy season.

I called up my niece in Guisijan, a barrio in the town of Laua-an next to Bugasong, just a few kilometers from Paliwan Bridge. Our conversation was brief because electricity had not been restored and her power bank was draining. Nobody could cross the rampaging waters of Paliwan River, she said.

The distance between San Jose de Buenavista, the capital town of Antique – one of the four provinces (Antique, Iloilo, Capiz and Aklan) in Panay island – and Guisijan is about 50 kilometers, crossing at least five rivers. I’m not sure about the exact number of rivers. Some may only be brooks (sapa) but they are all spanned by bridges, some short and others long.

The three known long bridges in Antique are Sibalom Pampang Bridge, made infamous by the ambush and killing of nine supporters of the late Evelio Javier, former Antique governor, on the eve of the 1984 parliamentary election; Cangaranan Bridge, also in Bugasong; and, Paliwan Bridge.

Those bridges are now made of concrete; they used to be made of wood. Walking on those wooden planks when buses were unable to cross the river was always a scary experience for me.

Washed away bridge approaches were a common occurrence during storms and typhoons. A bridge in the middle of a river was a common sight in Antique.

Traveling was an ordeal. We would take the bus up to one river bank, take a boat or ride on a raft, and take another bus on the other side of the river. The ordeal was repeated once we reached the next river. What usually was a one-hour bus ride had become a six to eight-hour agony on the road.

One can imagine the effect of this disturbance on the economic life of the people. Aside from the scarcity of goods, prices were tripled, even tenfold.

Antique roads, with countless potholes, were “abortion highways.” During the dry season, a bandana was a necessary accessory because of the dust that could turn your hair from black to white-gray.

In the past 15 to 20 years, traveling in Antique has greatly improved. Roads had been asphalted or cemented (although there are places where there’s a gap between cemented roads, making us suspect that part of the budget went to some people’s pockets).

Antique was hit hard by typhoon Yolanda in November 2013. After that, if I remember correctly, Antiqueños had a respite from damaging storms and typhoons. Until Paeng came last weekend.

Antique Gov. Rhodora Cadiao said in an interview on GMA-7 last Monday that she did not expect the province to be severely affected because it was not the center of the storm. She reported that Paeng left nine people dead. “Grabe talaga ang ulan (the rain was heavy),” she said, adding that there were places which experienced flooding for the first time.

As we are confronted with the loss of lives and damage to infrastructure and crops due to storm Paeng, we should be reminded that rain does not kill people. Do you know of anybody who died because of the rain?

Mahar Lagmay, executive director of the University of the Philippines Resilience Institute and the driving force behind Project Noah (Nationwide Operational Assessment of Hazards), said, “Rainfall is not a hazard.”

But, Lagmay said, somebody needs to translate that rainfall amount in the future into hazard maps that will be used by communities to adapt to climate change.

Cadiao’s lament was exactly what Lagmay shared with VERA Files in an interview last Friday, hours before Paeng came.

“Hindi ba kapag nagkakaroon ng mga disaster, tapos may biktima na iinterbyuhin ng media, ano ba sinasabi ng mga tao? Hindi ba commonly, sinasabi nila ay: ‘First time nangyari ito. Hindi pa binabaha dito dati. Ngayon lang namin nakita ito. Ngayon lang kami nakakita ng ganito kalaking storm surge. Ngayon lang kami nakakita ng ganito kalaking baha. Hindi pa nagkakaroon ng landslides’.”

(Isn’t it that whenever there’s a disaster, when a victim is interviewed by the media, what do they say? Commonly, they say: ‘It’s the first time that this has happened. This place had not been flooded. We experienced it just now. It’s only now that we saw that huge storm surge.
It’s only now that we saw such massive floods. Never have we had landslides.)

Lagmay said: “It only tells us that, aba, we failed to anticipate. ‘Yun lang ang (That’s the) collective meaning nun, eh. Bakit lahat ‘yan sinasabi nila na ngayon lang (Why are they all saying), first time, first time. It only tells us that we failed; they failed to anticipate the bigger event than what they have experienced.

“And that also tells us that we need really to change it to prepare for the bigger impacts. The impacts that will be brought about by climate change; those that are predicted by climate scientists from all over the world that can happen in the future … and it may be happening now.”

Why Gina Lopez says she has no caldero?

Incoming president Rodrigo Duterte chooses anti-mining advocate Gina Lopez as environment secretary.

Incoming president Rodrigo Duterte chooses anti-mining advocate Gina Lopez as environment secretary.

A video of the exchange between Gina Lopez, incoming President Rodrigo Duterte’s choice as secretary of Environment and Natural Resources, and a pro-mining advocate is going the rounds of social media.

Lopez was asking the man to choose between food and minerals because she argued that mining that extracts minerals from underneath the ground destroys the land where man produce food. Apparently Lopez has not heard of responsible mining.

Apparently also, the pro-mining man mentioned the things that we use in our daily lives that came from mining such as toothpaste.
Here’s the exchange that followed:

Lopez: Kumakain ka ba? Ano ang mas importante, toothpaste o pagkain ? …Ano ang pipiliin mo, mineral o pagkain?

Pro-mining person: Both.

Lopez: Ay hindi pwede.

Pro-mining person:… pagkain, may kaldero ka o wala?

Lopez: Wala.

Pro-mining person: Wala kang kaldero?

Very revealing exchange. The pro-mining guy probably brought up caldero because you need that to cook food. A caldero or any cooking utensil including rice cooker contains metals that were mined from underground.

But then Lopez was probably telling the truth when she said she has no caldero because maybe she does not cook. For all we know she doesn’t know what a caldero is. She probably eats out or she orders and food is delivered to her. She has the means to do that.

She should be told that the food that was delivered to her was cooked in a caldero. When she eats, she uses plate, fork and spoon. She drinks her water from a glass. Those things contain minerals that came from mining.

Strange because in an article she wrote in Rogue Magazine, she revealed that when she was in Africa during her Ashram days, she cooked.

When Lopez was arguing with the guy,she was holding a microphone to deliver her message. That microphone contains metals from mining.

In that forum, Lopez was wearing a red dress. We imagine she was wearing shoes. Those were produced by machines that contained metals mined from the earth. If mining is totally banned, there would be no sewing machines, no needles and pins needed to make clothes and shoes. Gina would have to wear leaves just like Adam and Eve.

Did Lopez walk from her house to the venue of the forum? If she took a car, she was being untrue to her anti-mining advocacy because a car contains metals produced by mining. There would be no vehicles without mining. There would be no airplanes, no trains without mining.

The forum was held in an air-conditioned room. An aircon unit contains metals from beneath the ground that can only be obtained by mining. We imagine that the rooms in Lopez’s house are air-conditioned. Her house, we imagine, is sturdy because it is made of concrete and steel. She is able to sleep well and not exposed to the sun and the rain because materials from mining sheltered her from the elements.

Does she have a cellphone? She should throw that away because that contains many things from underground obtained through mining. Same with computers.

Lopez’s family is in communications, a business that is dependent on equipment and tools made of materials from mining. To use and enjoy the fruits of mining and denounce mining at the same time is the height of hypocrisy.

Why Gina Lopez says she has no caldero?

Incoming president Rodrigo Duterte chooses anti-mining advocate Gina Lopez as environment secretary.

Incoming president Rodrigo Duterte chooses anti-mining advocate Gina Lopez as environment secretary.

A video of the exchange between Gina Lopez, incoming President Rodrigo Duterte’s choice as secretary of Environment and Natural Resources, and a pro-mining advocate is going the rounds of social media.

Lopez was asking the man to choose between food and minerals because she argued that mining that extracts minerals from underneath the ground destroys the land where man produce food. Apparently Lopez has not heard of responsible mining.

Apparently also, the pro-mining man mentioned the things that we use in our daily lives that came from mining such as toothpaste.
Here’s the exchange that followed:

Lopez: Kumakain ka ba? Ano ang mas importante, toothpaste o pagkain ? …Ano ang pipiliin mo, mineral o pagkain?

Pro-mining person: Both.

Lopez: Ay hindi pwede.

Pro-mining person:… pagkain, may kaldero ka o wala?

Lopez: Wala.

Pro-mining person: Wala kang kaldero?

Very revealing exchange. The pro-mining guy probably brought up caldero because you need that to cook food. A caldero or any cooking utensil including rice cooker contains metals that were mined from underground.

But then Lopez was probably telling the truth when she said she has no caldero because maybe she does not cook. For all we know she doesn’t know what a caldero is. She probably eats out or she orders and food is delivered to her. She has the means to do that.

She should be told that the food that was delivered to her was cooked in a caldero. When she eats, she uses plate, fork and spoon. She drinks her water from a glass. Those things contain minerals that came from mining.

Strange because in an article she wrote in Rogue Magazine, she revealed that when she was in Africa during her Ashram days, she cooked.

When Lopez was arguing with the guy,she was holding a microphone to deliver her message. That microphone contains metals from mining.

In that forum, Lopez was wearing a red dress. We imagine she was wearing shoes. Those were produced by machines that contained metals mined from the earth. If mining is totally banned, there would be no sewing machines, no needles and pins needed to make clothes and shoes. Gina would have to wear leaves just like Adam and Eve.

Did Lopez walk from her house to the venue of the forum? If she took a car, she was being untrue to her anti-mining advocacy because a car contains metals produced by mining. There would be no vehicles without mining. There would be no airplanes, no trains without mining.

The forum was held in an air-conditioned room. An aircon unit contains metals from beneath the ground that can only be obtained by mining. We imagine that the rooms in Lopez’s house are air-conditioned. Her house, we imagine, is sturdy because it is made of concrete and steel. She is able to sleep well and not exposed to the sun and the rain because materials from mining sheltered her from the elements.

Does she have a cellphone? She should throw that away because that contains many things from underground obtained through mining. Same with computers.

Lopez’s family is in communications, a business that is dependent on equipment and tools made of materials from mining. To use and enjoy the fruits of mining and denounce mining at the same time is the height of hypocrisy.

DENR, the Church and the nickel ore stockpile in Manicani

Environment Secretary Ramon Paje

Environment Secretary Ramon Paje

Has the government relinquished its duty of regulating the mining industry to the Catholic Church?

That’s the question I asked Environment Secretary Ramon Paje when he said that Hinatuan Mining Corporation (HMC) has to get the approval of the church to their request to remove the 1.1 million metric tons nickel ore stockpile in Manicani which poses risk to the environment minerals pose this rainy season.

Way back 2003 (the Environment secretary then was Heherson Alvarez), the Mines and Geoscience Bureau and Environmental Management Bureau of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources investigated and evaluated the impacts of mining operations in Manicani and Homonhon islands in Guiuan, Eastern Samar and the recommendation on the stockpile was, “while the operations of Hinatuan remains suspended, all available ore materials stockpiled form shipment must be disposed of immediately as these materials may cause siltation and water pollution along the seashore subject, however, to compliance with the other requirements of the DENR, MGB and EMB, as well as with the pertinent laws, rules and regulations.”

Does the Catholic Church have the veto power on decisions and recommendations by the DENR?

Paje clarified that it’s not that they have relinquished their job to the church but it would be good for everyone especially to the mining company to have the cooperation of the community including the Church.

Majority of the community, according to a joint resolution by the officials Manicani’s four barangays (Buenavista, Hamorawon, San Jose and Banaag) are for the disposal of the stockpile.

Manicani residents Nemesio and Adela Abucejo in their new house built, with assistance from Nickel Asia Corp. after Yolanda destroyed their old house house.

Manicani residents Nemesio and Adela Abucejo in their new house built, with assistance from Nickel Asia Corp. after Yolanda destroyed their old house house.

“With authoritative basis (survey results vis-à-vis those who like the disposal of the stockpiles and to those who don’t like) let it be set for record purposes in this joint resolution that all throughout the island of Manicani there are 87% of the constituents who ardently desire to have the stockpiles removed by Hinatuan Mining Corporation and 13 % don’t want that the same be removed,” the barangay officials said in a resolution sent to Bishop Crispin B. Varquez, bishop of the diocese of Borongan; DENR Secretary Ramon J.P. Paje; MGB Director Leo L. Jasareno; and Regional Director Alilo C. Ensomo, Jr. of MGB, Reg.8.

The joint resolution also cited the July 1, 2014 order of Jasareno to allow and have the loading of the nickel ore stockpile be expedited “so as this island will be free from the “hazards” posed by it during the rainy days.

Anti-mining protest in Manicani.

Anti-mining protest in Manicani.

Manicani residents were lucky that when super typhoon Yolanda struck the island almost two years ago,the stockpile, which had been there since 1991, didn’t cause much harm to the island and its residents. But, Jose Bayani Baylon, vice president for Communications of Nickel Asia Corporation, HMC’s mother company, said Yolanda was mostly strong winds and not much rain. It’s a different case with the amihan.

Baylon said due to the huge volume of the stockpile which consists mostly of low-grade ore, it would take about two years to have it all transported for processing to another NAC subsidiary before it could be sold to the market. That would mean jobs for residents of Manicani.

“Sabi ko nga, we can wait until the next administration… We can wait for another year. But that would mean that the islanders would have no source of income,” Baylon said.

Baylon also stressed that what HMC is asking DENR is permission to remove the ore stockpile from the island, not to resume mining operations which was suspended in many years.

Employment opprtunities offered by HMC.

Employment opprtunities offered by HMC.

Baylon said Regional Director Alilo C. Ensomo, Jr. of MGB, Reg.8, who was earlier been instructed to “Act accordingly” on HMC’s request to remove the stockpile from the island was about to issue the permit but Paje told him to “hold it.”

There must be other reasons why Paje is withholding the permit. Using the bishop of Borongan’s opposition is a lame excuse. DENR is in a better position than the bishop to assess the real risks of that nickel ore stockpile as well as the benefits for the people of Manicani with its removal from the island.

The DENR as the regulator in the mining industry gives importance to consensus-building.
However, as articulated in the national Minerals Policy, “… in case of unreasonable/unjustifiable objections to impasse, an informed majority public acceptance and support shall be acceptable.”

DENR, the Church and the nickel ore stockpile in Manicani

Environment Secretary Ramon Paje

Environment Secretary Ramon Paje

Has the government relinquished its duty of regulating the mining industry to the Catholic Church?

That’s the question I asked Environment Secretary Ramon Paje when he said that Hinatuan Mining Corporation (HMC) has to get the approval of the church to their request to remove the 1.1 million metric tons nickel ore stockpile in Manicani which poses risk to the environment minerals pose this rainy season.

Way back 2003 (the Environment secretary then was Heherson Alvarez), the Mines and Geoscience Bureau and Environmental Management Bureau of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources investigated and evaluated the impacts of mining operations in Manicani and Homonhon islands in Guiuan, Eastern Samar and the recommendation on the stockpile was, “while the operations of Hinatuan remains suspended, all available ore materials stockpiled form shipment must be disposed of immediately as these materials may cause siltation and water pollution along the seashore subject, however, to compliance with the other requirements of the DENR, MGB and EMB, as well as with the pertinent laws, rules and regulations.”

Does the Catholic Church have the veto power on decisions and recommendations by the DENR?

Paje clarified that it’s not that they have relinquished their job to the church but it would be good for everyone especially to the mining company to have the cooperation of the community including the Church.

Majority of the community, according to a joint resolution by the officials Manicani’s four barangays (Buenavista, Hamorawon, San Jose and Banaag) are for the disposal of the stockpile.

Manicani residents Nemesio and Adela Abucejo in their new house built, with assistance from Nickel Asia Corp. after Yolanda destroyed their old house house.

Manicani residents Nemesio and Adela Abucejo in their new house built, with assistance from Nickel Asia Corp. after Yolanda destroyed their old house house.

“With authoritative basis (survey results vis-à-vis those who like the disposal of the stockpiles and to those who don’t like) let it be set for record purposes in this joint resolution that all throughout the island of Manicani there are 87% of the constituents who ardently desire to have the stockpiles removed by Hinatuan Mining Corporation and 13 % don’t want that the same be removed,” the barangay officials said in a resolution sent to Bishop Crispin B. Varquez, bishop of the diocese of Borongan; DENR Secretary Ramon J.P. Paje; MGB Director Leo L. Jasareno; and Regional Director Alilo C. Ensomo, Jr. of MGB, Reg.8.

The joint resolution also cited the July 1, 2014 order of Jasareno to allow and have the loading of the nickel ore stockpile be expedited “so as this island will be free from the “hazards” posed by it during the rainy days.

Anti-mining protest in Manicani.

Anti-mining protest in Manicani.

Manicani residents were lucky that when super typhoon Yolanda struck the island almost two years ago,the stockpile, which had been there since 1991, didn’t cause much harm to the island and its residents. But, Jose Bayani Baylon, vice president for Communications of Nickel Asia Corporation, HMC’s mother company, said Yolanda was mostly strong winds and not much rain. It’s a different case with the amihan.

Baylon said due to the huge volume of the stockpile which consists mostly of low-grade ore, it would take about two years to have it all transported for processing to another NAC subsidiary before it could be sold to the market. That would mean jobs for residents of Manicani.

“Sabi ko nga, we can wait until the next administration… We can wait for another year. But that would mean that the islanders would have no source of income,” Baylon said.

Baylon also stressed that what HMC is asking DENR is permission to remove the ore stockpile from the island, not to resume mining operations which was suspended in many years.

Employment opprtunities offered by HMC.

Employment opprtunities offered by HMC.

Baylon said Regional Director Alilo C. Ensomo, Jr. of MGB, Reg.8, who was earlier been instructed to “Act accordingly” on HMC’s request to remove the stockpile from the island was about to issue the permit but Paje told him to “hold it.”

There must be other reasons why Paje is withholding the permit. Using the bishop of Borongan’s opposition is a lame excuse. DENR is in a better position than the bishop to assess the real risks of that nickel ore stockpile as well as the benefits for the people of Manicani with its removal from the island.

The DENR as the regulator in the mining industry gives importance to consensus-building.
However, as articulated in the national Minerals Policy, “… in case of unreasonable/unjustifiable objections to impasse, an informed majority public acceptance and support shall be acceptable.”