Social media raises demand for honesty from candidates

Two stories that generated passionate exchanges in social media the past days underscore how new media is being used to demand transparency and honesty from candidates and their staff in the campaign for the May elections.

Brian Llamanzares. Photo from Rappler

Brian Llamanzares. Photo from Rappler

The first story was about the shoes of Brian Llamanzares, son of presidential candidate Grace Poe of the Partido Galing at Puso and the other was the Instagram post of Marikina Rep. Miro Quimbo, who is the spokesman of the Aquino administration’s Liberal Party, whose standard bearer is Mar Roxas.

The story about the Llamanzares’ shoes was a scoop by the online media Rappler. Brian posted what seemed at first as a harmless photo until someone with a keen eye on sports shoes at Rappler noticed that the 23-year old, who once worked with CNN Philippines, was wearing a limited edition 2015 Nike Mag10 Back to the Future II Marty McFly.

That shoes sold for $19,999 equivalent to almost P900,000 in Philippine pesos. Nearly a million pesos for a pair of shoes.

Why so expensive?

As explained by a blogger Rod Magaru, “last September of 2011, a total of 1,500 pairs of Nike Mag10 were auctioned on eBay with the intention of donating its proceeds to Michael J Fox Foundation for Parkinsons Disease Research. They added 10 more pairs in a deluxe package and they were able to sell everything on that year.”

In a country where many workers earn less than P500 a day, wearing almost a million peso pair of shoes is scandalous indeed. It’s worse if your mother is running for president promising to help the poor.

Rappler’s story went viral in social media, shared and commented on by people supporting Grace Poe’s rivals in the presidential contest.

Llamanzares’ explanation that he “ bought it online at P10,000 from my own savings” was drowned by criticisms of “conspicuous consumption.” It didn’t help that Grace Poe came to his son’s defense without addressing the issue but only to defend Brian’s right to buy what he likes as long as he earned the money honestly.

It took Magaru and a sneaker store owner Antonio Aguirre Jr., to point out that what Llamanzares bought was “knockoff edition” of the Nike Mag 10 which sells online from $125 to $385. Minus the euphemism, Brian’s Nike Mag10 is fake.

Nike Mag10 for $122

Nike Mag10 for $122

Llamanzares later on apologized on TV. He said: “I apologize if anyone was offended by my shoes, it was never my intention to upset anyone. I just wanted to buy something for myself after saving up for months.I don’t know much about shoes and I’m not exactly a sneaker expert so when I saw these online at P10,000 and I liked the design, I saved up and bought the shoes.”

With “conspicuous consumption” belied, Poe bashers now say the issue is the morality and legality of her son buying counterfeit items which deprives the government of much needed earnings.

The incident should be a lesson for Brian: don’t buy fake items and stop posting photos in inane poses.

If the young Llamanzares was apologetic about the controversy, Quimbo exuded the arrogance that Aquino administration officials are known for when caught not telling the truth.

Quimbo posted on Instagram a photo of Mar Roxas with running mate Leni Robredo and Social Security System Board Director Eliza Antonino in an enclosed vehicle with a caption: “My busmates sa Tuwid Na Daan Caravan in Bicol.”

Busmates

Busmates in a helicopter

A sharp-eyed netizen, however, noticed the three were not in a bus but in a helicopter.

That post was preceded by Quimbo’s earlier announcements that the LP campaign caravan who went to Bicol was forced to take a 10-hour bus ride back to Manila because all flights were cancelled due to bad weather.

Mar Roxas haters immediately pounced on Quimbo. Netizen mariannecis asked:”Kelan pa po naging bus ang helicopter?” bsebastian 86 was more scathing: “Who do u think you’re fooling? Helicopter! Not bus! Trapo ka! Lying scum!”

Instead of explaining the disconnect between the chopper and the words “busmate,” Quimbo countered with contempt: ““Bawal corny dito. Of course it’s a chopper. Hello. Even my 6 year old knows that.”

Social media has its downsides. Truth usually gets derailed by speed. But speed also exposes the unedited side of people.

When they are people who are vying to be the country’s leaders, it’s better that we see them in their unvarnished form.

The Junjun Binay libel case vs Trillanes

Former Makati Mayor Junjun Binay: "Allegations besmirched my good name."

Former Makati Mayor Junjun Binay: “Allegations besmirched my good name.”

Sen. Antonio Trillanes IV. He said he will continue exposing the truth about the Binays.

Sen. Antonio Trillanes IV. He said he will continue exposing the truth about the Binays.

Telling the truth does not make one immune from libel suits.

Last Monday, Judge Dina Pestano Teves of the Makati Regional Trial Court 142, released the warrant of arrest for Sen. Antonio Trillanes IV after finding probable cause in the suit filed by former Makati Mayor Jejomar Erwin “Junjun” Binay Jr.

Trillanes, who is running for vice president as an independent candidate in the coming May election, is in Washington D.C. for the National Prayer Breakfast, an annual event hosted by members of the United States Congress and organized by a Christian Fellowship Foundation attended by some 3,500 guests from all over the world. The U.S. president usually attends the event held every first Thursday of February.

But the senator sent his reaction to the news about the warrant of arrest for him. “If the Binay family believes that I can be intimidated and threatened from exposing them, they are badly mistaken. I will do everything I can to make sure that plunderers will not rule this country again”, he said.

His lawyer, Rey Robles, said they have not yet received the official copy of the investigating prosecutor’s Resolution. But he assured the public that the moment the senator arrives “he will voluntarily submit himself to the jurisdiction of the Honorable Court, if so required.”

Robles added: “This is without prejudice to the Senator’s right to file a motion for reconsideration or even appeal said resolution to the Department of Justice, if warranted by the circumstances.”

Having survived seven years of detention for standing up to the most powerful person of the land, a libel suit is not something that would make the crusading senator cower in fear.

The libel suit stemmed from media interviews after he filed a Senate resolution in April last year to investigate the alleged “Justice for sale” practice in the Court of Appeals and other branches of the judiciary following the March 16, 2015 temporary restraining order issued by the C.A. on the suspension by the Ombudsman of Junjun Binay in connection with the investigation of the alleged overpriced construction of the Makati Parking Building.

Trillanes, citing “reliable sources privy to the matter”, said, “a lawyer by the name of Pancho Villaraza facilitated the transaction and talked to Associate Justices Reyes and Acosta and each of them received twenty million pesos for the TRO they issued. When the Ombudsman, DILG, and DOJ did not recognize the TRO, a second transaction was allegedly consummated with Associate Justices Reyes and Acosta allegedly receiving an additional five million pesos each upon the issuance of a writ of permanent injunction. This was purportedly the reason why the concerned CA division issued the writ of preliminary injunction with undue and inordinate haste long before its TRO is supposed to elapse.”
The CA associate justices Trillanes referred to were Jose Reyes Jr. and Francisco Acosta. Pancho Villaraza is the well known lawyer Arthur Villaraza, who is reportedly supporting the presidential bid of Vice President Jejomar Binay.

In filing the libel suit against Trillanes, Junjun Binay said “The damaging and ruinous claims spewed out by respondent Trillanes are mere concoctions and fabrications with no other purpose than to malign, discredit, ruin my reputation, and besmirch my good name as well as that of my family.”

Trillanes is also facing a contempt case before the CA.

Trillanes invoked parliamentary immunity and freedom of speech as the case of the TRO was connected with the investigation of the overpriced Makati Parking Building which had led to other alleged irregularities in Makati and exposed the wealth of the Binays including the sprawling Hacienda in Batangas.

TROs for sale is an open secret in the legal community. It’s something that everybody seems helpless about and has come to accept. But truthfulness is not a defense in libel.

The elements of libel are publication, sharing with others; identifiability; imputation of vice, defect or crime; malice (ill-motive). It carries a minimum punishment of six months and maximum punishment is six years and a fine.

Actually the issuance of that TRO was a brief victory for Junjun Binay because last October, in an administrative case, the Ombudsman ordered his dismissal and perpetual disqualification from holding a public office.

The Binays have also included Trillanes in a P200 million damage suit they filed against their detractors including Ombudsman Conchita Carpio Morales, Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas Governor Amando Tetangco Jr., the Philippine Daily Inquirer, the Anti-Money Laundering Council.

Things are still unfolding.

What happens if winner in May elections is disqualified?

Of the eight presidential candidates that the Commission on Elections approved to be listed in the ballots for the May 9, 2016 elections, two are facing disqualification cases: Grace Poe and Rodrigo Duterte.

Grace Poe and Escudero oblige a selfie with student in Cebu.

Grace Poe and Escudero oblige a selfie with student in Cebu.

The eight names that Comelec said would be in the ballots are: Jojo Binay of the United Nationalist Alliance (UNA); Miriam Defensor Santiago of the People’s Reform Party (PRP); Rody Duterte of Partido Demokratiko Pilipino-Lakas ng Bayan (PDP-Laban); Mel Mendoza of Pwersa ng Masang Pilipino (PMP); Grace Poe, independent;Mar Roxas of Daang Matuwid Liberal Party (LP); Roy Señeres of Partido ng Mangagawa at Magsasaka Workers (WPPPMM); and Dante Valencia,independent.

Printing of the ballots will start on Feb. 1 although Senate President Franklin Drilon, an LP stalwart, is asking the poll body to delay it and wait for the resolution of the disqualification cases being heard by the Supreme Court.

Rodrigo Duterte

Rodrigo Duterte

The disqualification cases against Poe allege that she is not a natural-born Filipino citizen because, being a foundling, her parents are unknown and that she lacks the required Philippine residency of 10 years before the May 9 elections.

Duterte’s disqualification case centers on the validity of his substitution,Martin Diño, who withdrew his confused candidacy (he wanted to file a certificate of candidacy for president but the form that he used was for mayor of Pasay City) before the Comelec declared him a nuisance candidate.

Comelec is reported to be cool to Drilon’s request to wait for the SC decision before printing the ballots.
Now, what happens if the winner in the May 9 polls is the one facing disqualification cases and the High Court decided that he or she is not qualified?

Take the case of Poe. What happens if Poe wins and the Supreme Court decides that she is not qualified to run for president?
Lawyer Harry Roque, who is aiming for a seat in the House of Representative through the partylist group, Kabayan, said the crucial factor is proclamation.

Bongbong Marcos in Pasay City Jan. 24, 2016

Bongbong Marcos in Pasay City Jan. 24, 2016

If the Supreme Court decided before Poe is proclaimed that she is not qualified to become president, the candidate with the second highest number of votes will be proclaimed president. If Poe is number one and Binay is number two, Binay becomes president. If Duterte is number two, then it’s Duterte who will be president. If it’s Roxas, then Roxas will realize his dream of becoming president.

Now, if Poe has already been proclaimed winner of the 2016 elections, the cases against her becomes the jurisdiction of the Presidential Electoral Tribunal composed of all the Supreme Court justices.

No problem if PET declared her qualified. She goes on with her presidency.

But if the PET declared her disqualified, the elected and proclaimed vice- president becomes president.

In the latest survey of the Social Weather Stations, Poe’s running mate, Chiz Escudero, is leading the vice-presidential race but Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos, Jr., running mate of Santiago, is fast catching up.

A Marcos presidency in 2016 is not totally out of the picture.

This is a very interesting elections.

Duterte and Aesop’s fable about the frogs who desired a king

The frogs desiring a king (Illus by Harrison Weir, John Tenniel, Ernest Griset)

The frogs desiring a king (Illus by Harrison Weir, John Tenniel, Ernest Griset)

The frustration of the people over the ineptness of the Aquino government has made the “kamay na bakal” brand of leadership that Davao City Mayor Rodrigo Duterte appealing to many.

Former Human Rights Commission Chair Etta Rosales warned about the dangers of a leader who wants to play God.
Rosales said, ““These people who say we need a Duterte, they don’t think of the law. They don’t realize that if you don’t respect the law, it would affect also you and your family.”

She adds: “The moment you take the law in your hands and you think you can get away with it, then you become part of the problem, and that has been the way of all authoritarian rulers.”

Yesterday, Martin Diño, whose filing of the certificate of candidacy for president and subsequent withdrawal is still being processed by the Comelec, said in case Duterte wins, the latter will reimpose the death penalty six months into his presidency and have weekly executions of convicts of heinous crimes.

“Once na nanalo siya, itong death penalty ay [restored] within six months. Kapag ito ay na-restore na, we will implement it weekly. Gusto niya magkaroon ng atmosphere ng katahimikan,” Diño was quoted in an ABS-CBN interview.

This situation reminds of Aesop’s fable about the frogs who desired a king.

Illustration by Arthur Rackham. 1912 edition.

Illustration by Arthur Rackham. 1912 edition.

“A long time ago, when the frogs lead a free and easy life in the lakes and ponds, they became disgruntled because everyone lived according to his own whim and chaos reigned.

“They gathered and petitioned the god Jupiter to let them have a king who would bring order into their lives and make them more responsible.

“Knowing how foolish the frogs were, Jupiter smiled at their request and threw down a log into the lake. ‘There’s your king, ‘he declared.

“The log made such a splash that it terrified the poor frogs, who dived under water and into the mud. No one dared to come within ten leaps of the spot where it lay in stillness. Eventually, one frog, who was bolder than the rest, ventured to pop his head above the water and watch their new king at a respectful distance.

“When some others soon perceived that the log was lying stock-still, they began to swim up to it and around it. At last they grew so bold that they leaped upon it and treated it with the greatest contempt.

“Dissatisfied with such a tame ruler they immediately petitioned Jupiter a second time to grant them a more active king.

“This time Jupiter sent them a stork and no sooner did the bird arrive than he began seizing and devouring them one by one as fast as he could.”

Moral of the story: When you desire for change, make sure it’s an improvement. Don’t make the mistake of jumping from the frying pan to the fire.

The worst is yet to come for Binay

Vice President Jejomar Binay. Thanks to Inquirer for photo.

Vice President Jejomar Binay. Thanks to Inquirer for photo.

Pulse Asia’s latest poll on approval and trust ratings of top government officials showed Vice President Jejomar Binay suffering a huge minus 15 drop in performance and minus 18 in trust in the span of three months.

Approval of President Aquino’s performance remained the same at 54 percent in June 2015 and during last month’s survey (Sept. 8 to 14). The people’s trust for him registered a minimal decline, from 50 percent last June to 49 percent last month.

The performance and trust rating for Senate President Franklin Drilon, House Speaker Feliciano Belmonte, Jr. and Supreme Court Justice Lourdes Sereno remained almost the same, moving only one or three percent.

The nationwide survey conducted among 2,400 respondents showed that from 58 percent who approved of Binay’s performance in June 2015, only 43 percent expressed satisfaction with his performance. The number of those who disapproved increased from 18 in June to 26 percent last month.

The number of those undecided about his performance increased from 24 to 31 percent.

In the trust department, Binay‘s rating decreased from 57 percent in June to 39 percent last month.

But survey ratings should be the least of Binay’s concern now as the Ombudsman is set to file either today or next week with the Sandiganbayan graft charges against him in connection with the alleged anomalous bidding of the building project in Makati.

That’s only for violation of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act. It’s not plunder. Which means he can post bail and continue with his presidential candidacy, as he has announced.

The information we got, however, is it’s Binay’s son, suspended Makati Mayor Junjun Binay, who will finally be ordered dismissed by the Ombudsman next week, that would be another major blow on Binay.

Charges will also be filed against the younger Binay with the Sandiganbayan. If it’s plunder, he faces arrest.

Meanwhile the meeting of Sen. Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. with Davao City Mayor Rodrigo Duterte casts doubt on a Binay-Marcos tandem.

Sources said the Marcos grand dame, Imelda, approved of it but there’s a lot of resistance from other members of the family and staff of Sen. Marcos.

After Sen. Gringo Honasan declined his offer to be his running mate, we learned Binay is talking with Rep. Lito Atienza.